Centre for Science and Technology Studies Centre for Science and Technology Studies 2333AL Leiden Zuid Holland 31715273909

Personal evaluation in academic book reviews (1950–2000)

Sjang ten Hagen

Fri 3 Mar 2023 | 15:00 - 16:15 (CET)
CWTS and Online
Sjang ten Hagen

Join Webinar Online

How have the evaluative norms and habits of academic communities changed historically? My research explores this issue by examining the history of book reviewing in the humanities and sciences. Through analyzing a sample of 1,224 book reviews published in the journals The American Historical Review, Contemporary Psychology and Physics Today between 1950 and 2000, I found that the evaluation of books’ contents often overlapped with the evaluation of books’ authors. Historians, physicists, and psychologists routinely named the personal qualities of authors in their book reviews. For example, they would praise some authors for exhibiting “carefulness,” “honesty,” or “judiciousness,” while criticizing others for lacking these particular qualities. In my talk, I show that these acedemic norms for personal evaluation were strikingly similar across the academic spectrum, even if some personal qualities (such as objectivity) were deemed more important in some disciplines than in others.


Sjang ten Hagen (Institute for History, Leiden University)


Build on Applepie CMS by Waltman Development